BY CHUKS COLLINS, AWKA
ALOR community in Idemili South Local Council of Anambra State, on Monday, November 16, erupted in excitement and joyous celebration as news filtered in that the Court of Appeal, Asaba Division, had affirmed the judgment of an Anambra State High Court, which dethroned McAnthony Elibe Okonkwo as the traditional ruler of the community.
The appellate court had on October 30, this year, upheld Okonkwo’s dethronement and removal by the Federal High Court onFebruary 17, 2022.
The higher court had dismissed the appeal brought before it by the former monarch, and upheld the lower court judgment invalidating Okonkwo’s selection, installation and recognition as the Igwe of Alor.
Consequently, the court of appeal ruling confirms the removal of Okonkwo as traditional ruler of Alor.
Okonkwo’s claim to the Igweship was challenged and the court averred that the process through which he was thrown up did not comply with the Alor People’s Convention Constitution and the Traditional Rulers’ Law of Anambra State, and that the government-appointed caretaker committee lacked the legal authority to conduct the selection process that produced Okonkwo.
By the judgment, Frank Nwabufo Okoye, Okonkwo and others lost the appeal against the Incorporated Trustees of Alor Peoples Assembly (APA) and Uzoma Igbonwa (Okife Alor).
The appellate court judgment identified several important defects, including that Okonkwo could not establish that he possessed the required Ozo title when he applied and was screened.
The Justices rejected the argument that a candidate could qualify by promising to obtain the title before installation.
The court pointed to improper traditional installation, saying the constitution requires specific traditional procedures, including the presentation of the staff of office by the appropriate Isigwu family representative (the Ezeofor Alor), and capping by the appropriate senior Ozo title holder in Uruezeani Village.
The higher court upheld findings that those requirements were not properly followed.
In addition, the appellate court held that the caretaker committee, although appointed by the Anambra State Government to restore order in the community, exceeded its authority, as it did not have the legal authority to conduct new Igwe selection, relying on the earlier judicial invalidation of the statutory provision under which broader powers were claimed.



